Im a little confused about this
She dosen't mean that Andy died 8 years ago?
Or did she mean the car accident with Phoebe?
Darklighter: That's it. It's the only way. It's the only way to save the one's I love. I should've done it before. Eight years ago.
Prue: I didn't want to.
Darklighter: But if I had, loved ones would still be alive today. Like Andy. I'm responsible for Andy.
(Prue starts crying.)
Prue: Andy.
Darklighter: It's all my fault. Jump. Jump.