Why??

[lover]

that's exactly my point ...prue gave up everything for her sisters...she even let Andy die...Phoebe had to see her lover boy...the demon who tried to hurt the charmed ones...he didn't,so??should i thank him??if Phoebe would kill him in season 3 when she should have Prue would be alive...so,i blame both of them... especially Phoebe

[jenny777]

[valentina2]

Good question! Why did Prue die?? WHY??
Because she gave her life to save her sister's life, because Phoebe wasn't there where she needed her, probably because Leo tryed to save Piper first but the first reason is because apperently for Phoebe, Cole's life was more important than Prue's one... so Shax did it.

I just don't get it: Phoebe should know that Cole belonged to the evil anyway and nothing and no one could save him for that. Love is blind but in this case her love for him killed Prue and almost Piper.