Do you ever wonder what would have happened if....

[marissalu415]

Rose McGowan had been on the show from the beginning instead of Alyssa Milano? Now i have nothing against Alyssa Milano, but i think if it would have been Rose McGowan from the start, Shannen might have stayed on the show longer. I think they're friends, or at least on friendly terms so i think they would have gotten along really well. Maybe Prue wouldn't have had to die.... I know this is kind of pointless, but i just wonder what it would have been like. The show would have been so different without Phoebe, so idk if i would like that. But maybe i woudn't have minded if it meant Prue didnt' have to die. Anyway, just felt like throwing that out there.

[brianne]

well believe it or not... i do wonder sometimes...

[thefifthsister]

I do wonder....

but it makes me smile to think of everything Shannen has done since then!

[littlemissbad]

what we have to rember is that no one knows why our dear shannen left charmed, they were her own reasons and are very personal to her.
so weather or not rose was there at the start shannen may have still left the show.
no one knows if its true that it was because of whats her name..... that shannen left.

just food for thought. xoxoxo

[brianne]

well i have nothing against phoebe or alyssa, i was just wondering... but hey like you've said... she has her reasons...

[littlemissbad]

[paulinepl]

Hmmm... however it'd happen, if Shannen didn't want to stay there, I agree with her and for me it doesn't matter what the Charmed would like without Phoebe, with Prue - if she wanted to left Charmed, I won't wondering why it happened..

[marissalu415]

yeah i know that no one knows for sure why she left, but i just thought it would be interesting with Rose McGowan from the start. But yeah you're right chucklemagne, Paige would have had a different power. That would have been weird.

[brianne]

really weird i think... but i think it would be fun... yah know... paige is really funny...